I've kept quiet on the entire subject of mommy drinking during playdates because the intensity of the debates created a curiously loud sucking noise in my head. Kind of like any mention of Fox news,
you know? But today I saw yet another excruciatingly dumb study aimed
at telling mommies that they don't measure up, and I just had to
comment.
These studies are amazing. And they are wrapped in - can I just say
it? -- absolute trash articles that reporters should blush to write.
The pseudo-logical gem that gets my personal "Idiot Psychologist Run
Amok" award is an article from 2000 called Saying "That's Great" May Not Be.
The premise of the "That's Great may not be" article is that you shouldn't praise your child unless you should. Well, duh.
But then, some writer decided to inflate this 20-second premise into
a whole article, and came up with scintillating quotes like: "Some
child-rearing experts say a steady stream of praise can turn children
into praise addicts who lack confidence because they dismiss the value
of the compliments." (Yeah. this is how your typical 3 year old
thinks.) And of course they shoehorned in another expert saying that,
while some parents overpraise, ''most parents don't praise enough.
Praise is extremely important in building up a sense of children's own
abilities. For psychologists to suggest that you should limit praise
really undermines the idea of how we encourage children to feel good
about themselves."
What is this trash? And why is it being dumped on parents by the
boat load? Here's a theory: There are a lot of people out there who
want to earn money. In order to justify earning it, they are selling
anything that they can to "parents," because "parents" are a market
segment. And "you suck" will almost always catch a parent's attention.
I once picked up a Cosmo magazine
and was appalled Not only were the styles ghastly, but every single
article carried the message "You suck, but if you do THIS to your hair,
your body, your clothes, then ... you'll be able to pass and maybe some
man will have sex with you." Wow. What utter garbage. But this
time-proven "Let us tell you how you suck THIS time" approach really
bothers me when it's aimed at parents.
If you're an overscheduled parent, scanning this psych quote-larded
garbage while frantically multitasking, the "you suck because a study
says so" article undermines two things: first off, your gut instincts,
which should be generated by your cultural knowlege, memories,
knowledge, personality, parenting style, and logic. (Not to mention
the occasional phone call to your mom, even if she's really irritating.) Secondly, it undermines your confidence - and confidence is one of the most important things that a parent can have.
"Don't praise your kids." What an incredibly stupid thing to write
about! If your kid is having developmental problems or is at a stage
where they are afraid to go down the slide, have a tendency to fight
with others, don't always wait their turn, are afraid of the slide, or
whatever other thing, of COURSE you will praise them! But of course an
article that says "You should pay attention to your kid and your kid's
development and do the things that you think are the right things to
do" is ... dull. It doesn't stir up controversy. Hard to get talking
heads to argue over something so sensible. Or even one of those
swashbuckling, female-baiting fembots.
And so we come to the new article that raises my hackles.
Study links big egos in youths to programs for self-esteem
is the title that the San Jose Mercury gave the article, although the
original article's title is: "Gen Y's Ego Trip takes a Nasty Turn,"
and it seems like one of the most amazing pieces of crap research that
I've seen in a long time.
According to this article, there's a new study out in which five
"researchers ... looked at the results of psychological surveys taken
by more than 16,000 college students across the country" since 1982.
According to the article, "the Narcissistic Personality Inventory
asks students to react to such statements as: 'If I ruled the world, it
would be a better place,' 'I think I am a special person' and 'I like
to be the center of attention.'
The study found that thirty percent more college students showed elevated narcissism in 2006 than in 1982."
Clearly shocking news, that someone older would find youth to be
narcissistic, although seriously, with those questions, what would they
expect? If the kids think that they could do a better job running the
country, well ... who says they're not right? But let's move on.
Here's where it gets amazing to me (and BTW, the ostensibly academic
leader of the study is also promoting her paperback this very week. Tacky.)
Why is this so? (I kid you not.) "Some of the increase in
narcissistic attitudes was probably caused by the self-esteem programs
that many elementary schools adopted 20 years ago, the study suggests.
It notes that nursery schools began to have children sing songs that
proclaim: 'I am special, I am special. Look at me.'"
The report also claims that "Those youngsters are now adolescents
obsessed with websites, such as MySpace and YouTube, that 'permit
self-promotion far beyond that allowed by traditional media."
Let me see if I have this right. The new kids coming up are
self-absorbed, shallow little jerks. This is because they sang "I'm a
good kid" songs in ... preschool. It's also because they play on the
computer and make pages on MySpace. Parents, you suck because you're
too permissive and haven't banned "I'm a good kid" songs from
preschools. And ... here's a new twist: KIDS, you suck, because ...
well, you just do.
Ha. Patent bull-hockey. So the boomers, the most amazingly
self-absorbed group of people in modern history, weren't even
measured? Kids today are like vanilla pudding next to people like
Abbie Hoffman and the cast of characters who worked hard to, oh, burn
down their colleges and just incidentally throw over an entire social
structure. Remember that decade? (And they're STILL narcissistic.
Check out this little gem written by a boomer.) And need I mention the fact that the boomer generation practically invented the crystal, aromatherapy, and self-knowledge movements? Personification of narcissism, folks. Jeez. Like, have the writers of this stupid article even heard of Esalen?
I think that the thing that irritates me so much about this article
is that the authors took an apparently serious study and turned it
into idiocy. Perhaps some simple logic could have helped. Or a
reading of the book by Twenge, who led the study.
Generation Me: Why Today's Young Americans are More Confident, Assertive, Entitled - and more Miserable than Ever Before
is the name of Twenge's book. It's apparently aimed at 18 year olds to
35 year olds, and she's now apparently trying to broaden her
application of the data, despite the fact that nowadays preschoolers
learn the days of the week in Chinese, how to read, and there is no
mention of self.
Twenge is on a narcissism kick. She thinks that it's the cause for
everything. OK. Whatever. Personally, I think that she should take
into consideration parents who think of their children as extensions of
themselves (e.g. multigenerational narcissism), the relentless pushing
of children to achieve. as opposed to taking time to find real
passions, and the over-intellectualizing of childhood. There's an
interesting Rudolf Steiner quote which says that if you intellectually
train children before the age of 5 or so (instead of focusing on their
spirit and their selves), they turn into materialists. What about that?
Ah, well, I suppose a discussion of the pros and cons of the study
wasn't what the authors were aiming for. They were aiming for a nice
little talking head nugget that would be carried on the nightly news.
And "You suck because your preschool works on self esteem" is certainly
catchy, if totally moronic.
Gotta go. Some of the other mommies and I are meeting at Peets Coffee to "cleanse" the local Kindergarten curriculum of any pesky self-esteem propaganda. Thank GOODNESS I discovered this blight early on.
This first appeared on the Silicon Valley Mom's blog
Recent Comments